
Martin St-Louis coached his first game behind the Montreal Canadiens bench on February 10, 2022. Nearly five years later, one thing remains remarkably consistent: his teams spend an awful lot of time sitting in the penalty box. Whether it's a matter of defensive structure, individual discipline or questionable officiating, the numbers have become difficult to ignore.
Through November 16, Montreal has played 386 games under St-Louis, compiling a record of 175-160-51 (.519 points percentage). During that stretch, the Canadiens have been assessed 1,432 minor penalties, the third-highest total in the NHL, behind Florida (1,553) and Anaheim (1,452). They've also accumulated 48 bench minors, seventh-most in the league. Overall, Montreal has taken 1,628 penalties while drawing 1,516 from its opponents, a net differential of minus-112. Only Anaheim has a worse ratio.
Unfortunately, the current season isn't offering much encouragement. Through 21 games, the Canadiens have already been assessed 102 penalties, fourth-most in the NHL, while drawing just 86. That's a minus-16 differential, with only Dallas having a worse record in that department. Quite frankly, that's mind-boggling, particularly when you consider the type of team Montreal is supposed to be.
Why are the Canadiens taking so many penalties?
Looking at the individual infractions this season, tripping leads the way with 19, followed by roughing (16), interference (13), holding (12), hooking (9), high-sticking (5) and holding the stick (4). There are probably several contributing factors, and not all of them are within the team's control. Let's not pretend NHL officiating is an exact science. Consistency has been a problem for years, as I discussed in my previous article about refereeing. While questionable calls happen throughout the league, believing that every team is treated equally in every situation would be a little naive.
I'm not suggesting there's a conspiracy against Montreal, but there have been enough head-scratching decisions this season to make you wonder. The Canadiens have already had at least seven apparent goals disallowed, including three in one game against Detroit on October 10. Not all those decisions were questionable, and some were straightforward applications of the rules. However, the goaltender-interference decision involving Zachary Bolduc against Detroit generated legitimate debate. Add the other disallowed goals, including decisions against San Jose, Minnesota and Colorado, and it's understandable that Canadiens fans are becoming increasingly frustrated. Proving bias is another matter entirely, but suggesting that officiating is beyond scrutiny is equally ridiculous.
There are also things Montreal can control. The hybrid defensive system requires players to follow opponents through different areas of the defensive zone. When a defender loses coverage, falls behind his check or gets caught reaching for an opponent, the temptation to compensate with a stick infraction increases. Tripping, hooking, holding and interference can become the consequences of being half a step behind. That's a possible explanation, but it doesn't account for everything, particularly when you look at the physical makeup of this roster.
The roughing numbers are especially puzzling. Montreal has been called for roughing 16 times this season, yet this isn't a team built around intimidating opponents physically. Take the Florida Panthers, for example. They're a rough-and-tumble team, built to play a heavy, physical and often uncomfortable brand of hockey. Their players finish checks, get involved after the whistle and aren't particularly concerned about making friends along the way. Montreal, on the other hand, doesn't have that kind of lineup. Aside from the Xhekaj brothers and Josh Anderson, there aren't many Canadiens who would be considered particularly intimidating physical presences. Florian Xhekaj has played only seven games, while Arber has been relatively disciplined, with just six minor penalties to his name this season. So why are the Canadiens accumulating so many roughing calls? When a team that isn't particularly physical keeps getting penalized at a rate comparable to some of the league's more abrasive clubs, it only adds to the mystery.
The other problem is that Montreal isn't getting enough calls in return. A team relying on puck possession, an aggressive forecheck and sustained offensive-zone pressure should be generating opportunities to draw penalties. Instead, the Canadiens are regularly coming out on the wrong side of that equation. You would think that spending considerable time in the opposition's zone would eventually force defenders into mistakes, but the numbers aren't reflecting that. Whether it's a matter of missed calls, the way opponents defend Montreal or the Canadiens themselves not doing enough to draw infractions, the imbalance is difficult to explain.
The cost of spending time in the box
Here's what makes this particularly frustrating: Montreal has demonstrated that it can be a very competitive team at even strength. Its ability to generate offence and sustain pressure is an important part of its identity. Yet every unnecessary trip to the penalty box takes something away from those strengths. Players who should be contributing to the forecheck are killing penalties instead, offensive momentum disappears, line rotations get disrupted and players accumulate extra minutes that could otherwise be spent attacking. The more time a team spends defending with a man down, the less time it has to dictate the game.
And let's not overlook the special teams. With a power play operating at just 12.5% and a penalty kill sitting at 78.8%, these aren't exactly numbers that allow the Canadiens to shrug off an endless parade of penalties. When your own power play struggles to capitalize on opportunities, giving opponents more chances becomes an even more expensive habit. The Canadiens are making it harder to win games they should be perfectly capable of winning without constantly having to overcome their own mistakes.
There is a difference between playing aggressively and playing recklessly. A team can be physical, competitive and difficult to play against without constantly reaching, grabbing or taking unnecessary liberties. Discipline needs to be part of the team's identity, and that starts with the players, but the coaching staff also has a responsibility to address recurring problems. I'm not suggesting St-Louis can eliminate every penalty. Some are unavoidable, some are questionable, and some are simply part of playing hockey. But when the numbers become this consistent over several seasons, it's fair to ask whether something needs to change in the way this team defends and manages its emotions.
The Canadiens have enough work to do trying to win hockey games. They have a team capable of competing at even strength, and they should be making better use of that strength rather than continually giving opponents opportunities to take control. You can't spend half the evening putting out fires and expect to have much time left to build a house. And right now, the Habs seem to be handing out matches.

Leave a Reply