
We've all heard the rumours circulating for weeks about Montreal's interest in acquiring Dylan Larkin, who requested a trade from the Detroit Red Wings. Now, apparently, you can add another name to the Canadiens rumour mill: Sidney Crosby.
The Pittsburgh Penguins are struggling, and general manager Kyle Dubas has acknowledged that future-oriented moves could be necessary if things don't improve. That has naturally fuelled speculation about the future of the team's veteran players, including its captain. Crosby hasn't been declared available, but even the possibility of seeing the Cole Harbour, Nova Scotia native, who grew up a Canadiens fan, wearing the CH has been enough to get Montreal talking.
So, let's entertain the possibility for a moment. Which player would make more sense for the Canadiens?
Here's the thing. You're not acquiring Crosby at the peak of his career. He'll turn 40 next August and currently has 14 points in 22 games, a 53-point pace over an 84-game season. That's a considerable difference from last year's 74 points in 68 games. He still brings exceptional hockey intelligence, leadership and experience, but age eventually collects its dues. Even Sidney Crosby isn't exempt.
On the other hand, Larkin is 30, and his $8.7-million AAV contract runs through 2030-31. That's five additional seasons of contractual control beyond this one. He's a faster skater, while Crosby is physically stronger and arguably sees the ice better. Both are left-handed centres, good on faceoffs, and would make excellent second-line centres behind Nick Suzuki.
Both also carry an $8.7-million cap hit this season, but there's a significant difference in what comes next. Crosby is a pending UFA, meaning Montreal would have to consider the possibility of negotiating a new contract. Larkin comes with considerably more certainty.
In my humble opinion, if the acquisition costs are comparable, Larkin is the better investment. You simply get more mileage out of him. However, if Pittsburgh's asking price for Crosby is substantially lower than Detroit's demands for Larkin, I'd take Sid the Kid. His leadership and hockey sense would be invaluable to a young Canadiens group.
Sometimes, the best deal isn't necessarily the biggest name. It's the one that gives you the most hockey for the assets you surrender.
One condition, though. Michael Hage is a non-starter. I would not include him in either conversation.
And let's not forget Nikita Kucherov. The Canadiens should be keeping an eye on that situation as well, as we discussed in a recent article. There may be more than one interesting opportunity ahead for Kent Hughes.
ON THE FLY
🥞 Injuries are really starting to pile up for the Canadiens. It's encouraging to see Ivan Demidov skating again as he works his way back from his ankle injury. The power play could certainly use him right now.
🥞 It was good to see Jakub Dobeš have a strong outing in Carolina. You could see how happy his teammates were for him. A very likeable character, that Doby.
🥞 Lane Hutson is on fire and developing into a very special player, not just for the Canadiens but across the entire NHL.
🥞 Samuel Montembeault is nearing a return from injured reserve. It will be interesting to see whether he accepts a conditioning assignment in Laval, but also what Kent Hughes chooses to do with his goaltenders. Sending Jacob Fowler down after his performances might create a riot à la Rocket Richard!
🥞 Having just finished a stretch of seven games in 12 days, the Canadiens are entering a more normal week. They'll host the Los Angeles Kings on a rare Monday night game, travel to Colorado on Wednesday, then head to Las Vegas for a Saturday matinee.

Leave a Reply